top of page

Fogg's Model Applied to the Design of Sustainability Apps

Feb 28, 2019
12 min read

In 2017, 92% of European Union citizens considered climate change a serious problem (European Commission, 2017). Even so, concern does not always turn into concrete action, such as sorting waste, reducing energy consumption, or choosing more sustainable means of transport. This gap may be due to a range of psychological, social, and structural barriers [1]. The obstacles include a lack of information, ingrained habits, the influence of the social environment, economic constraints, and the absence of accessible infrastructure or alternatives (Gifford, 2011; Lorenzoni et al., 2007).


Fogg; Javier Trespalacios; Suforall

Suforall's Instagram


To understand how to narrow this gap between concern and action, B. J. Fogg's Behavior Model (Fogg Behavior Model, FBM) [2] offers a framework for analyzing the factors involved in performing a behavior. Applied to the design of apps and digital platforms, it helps identify the difficulties users run into and introduce features that make certain actions easier. This approach can be complemented by captology (Fogg, 2003), persuasive design, and gamification, concepts that are developed below.


The Fogg Model: Motivation, Ability, and Trigger

Fogg's Behavior Model establishes that a behavior occurs when three elements coincide at the same moment: motivation (M), ability (A) to act, and a trigger (T) able to set the action off. Fogg expresses this relationship with the conceptual formula B = MAT (Fogg, 2009). Motivation and ability partly offset each other: the simpler an action is, the less motivation it takes. However, even when both are sufficient, the behavior may not occur if no trigger appears at the right moment.


Fogg; Javier Trespalacios; Suforall; B=MAT

Fogg's Behavior Model. The curve shows that the easier an action is to perform, the less motivation is needed for a trigger to set it off


The FBM can be related to other approaches that study the factors influencing behavior, such as Ajzen's (1991) Theory of Planned Behavior. This theory explains that the intention to act depends on three factors: attitude toward the behavior, subjective norms (the social pressure or influence a person perceives), and perceived behavioral control, that is, the perception of the resources and difficulties that may make it easier or harder to carry out. While Ajzen analyzes the factors involved in forming the intention, Fogg focuses on the conditions that must coincide for a behavior to take place.


Motivation (M): what drives action

n the FBM, motivation is the impulse that leads a person to perform a behavior. Fogg (2009) identifies three main motivators, each with two poles: pleasure and pain, hope and fear, and social acceptance and rejection. These pairs reflect the wish to obtain pleasant experiences or avoid unpleasant ones, the expectation of achieving a positive result or preventing a negative one, and the search for acceptance or the fear of rejection by other people.


In the context of sustainability, motivation can also be linked to social influence. Knowing what other people do makes it possible to see which behaviors are usual in a community, and this can shape one's own decisions. For example, Nolan et al. (2008) observed that messages reporting the energy-saving behavior of other households could influence families' electricity consumption.


Ability (A): making the action simpler

or Fogg (2009), ability relates to how easy an action is to perform. The simpler it is, the less motivation is needed to carry it out. Fogg identifies six factors that affect that ease: the time available, money, physical effort, mental effort, deviation from social norms, and the degree to which the action departs from a person's habits. An action can be hard when any of these factors is an obstacle for the person.


From the standpoint of behavioral design, this approach makes it possible to identify which obstacles make an action difficult and which changes in the product, the service, or the environment could make it easier. In some cases, reducing the number of steps is enough; in others, it is necessary to provide information, resources, or conditions that make it possible to act.


In the context of sustainability, these principles can be applied to the design of apps through clear instructions and features that help overcome specific difficulties. For example, an app can show public transport routes, locate recycling points, or point to places that offer sustainable products or services. Its usefulness will also depend on those alternatives existing and being accessible to the person.


Trigger (T): the stimulus that activates behavior

A trigger is the stimulus that invites a person to perform a behavior at a given moment. It can be a notification, a visual cue, or an element of the environment. To be effective, it must be adapted to the person's motivation and ability at that moment. Fogg (2009) distinguishes three types of triggers:


  • Facilitators: used when the person is motivated to act but finds it difficult to do so. For example, an app can indicate which waste goes in which bin and show where the nearest collection point is.

  • Signals: remind a person of a behavior when they already have enough motivation and ability to perform it. For example, a notice reminding them of waste collection day.

  • Sparks: aim to awaken motivation when the person is able to act but does not find enough reasons to do so. For example, a message showing the estimated emission reduction they could achieve by using a bicycle instead of a car.


Captology and persuasive design: technology at the service of change

B. J. Fogg uses the term captology to refer to the study of computers as persuasive technologies, that is, as tools capable of influencing people's attitudes and behaviors (Fogg, 2003). Persuasive design applies these principles through features and interfaces intended to make certain behaviors easier or to promote them. In his book, Fogg (2003) describes seven types of persuasive technology tools:


  • Reduction: simplifying complex tasks, for example, turning the logging of a sustainable action into a single tap.

  • Tunneling: guiding the user through a sequence of steps, as in a process for assessing and reducing energy consumption.

  • Tailoring: adjusting information to the characteristics of a person or group, for example, offering sustainable transport recommendations based on the user's locality.

  • Suggestion: intervening at the right moment, for example, telling the user, before leaving home, when the next bus is due.

  • Self-monitoring: letting users observe their own behavior, such as how their electricity consumption changes over time.

  • Surveillance: using technology to observe a behavior and make that information visible to other people. For example, a system can show the energy consumption of different departments in a company and let their managers follow how each one is evolving. This function raises issues of privacy and control over workers, so it must be applied with transparency, clear criteria, and defined limits.

  • Conditioning: reinforcing certain behaviors through rewards, for example, awarding points for using sustainable means of transport.


Applied to sustainability, these tools can be used to simplify tasks, adapt information to each situation, offer recommendations at the right moment, and let people see how their own actions are evolving.


Gamification and social influence

Gamification consists of incorporating game design elements, such as points, badges, challenges, or levels, into contexts that are not games (Deterding et al., 2011). In the context of sustainability, a community could organize a collective challenge to reduce energy consumption over a month and show participants' progress. Sharing those results also makes it possible to publicly recognize the effort of those who take part.


However, accumulating points or earning badges does not guarantee an environmental improvement. If rewards depend only on the number of activities logged, participants may concentrate on earning points without any significant change in their behavior. For that reason, challenges and rewards should be tied to actions that can be assessed and, when possible, to their environmental results.


The influence of social norms can affect individual decisions. Knowing what other people do makes it possible to see which behaviors are usual, while signals of social approval or disapproval indicate which ones are accepted. Schultz et al. (2007) studied this effect on household energy consumption. When families were told how their consumption compared with the neighborhood average, the researchers observed that households consuming above that average tended to reduce it, while some of those consuming less increased their consumption. However, when a signal of social approval or disapproval was added, the researchers avoided this counterproductive effect.


Applying Fogg's model to digital platforms for sustainability

Social networks offer examples of how some features of an app can influence how its users participate. Instagram, for example, lets people post photographs, comment, and express approval through likes. From the standpoint of Fogg's model, these features can be analyzed as resources that make interaction easier and provide social recognition. Notifications can also act as signals that invite people to return to the app. An experimental study that simulated how Instagram works found that adolescents were more likely to like photographs that had already piled up many approvals (Sherman et al., 2016). The result shows the influence that other users' approval can have, although it does not allow us to conclude that this interaction produces sustainable behaviors. Sharing environmental information can give visibility to certain initiatives, but the challenge is to make that participation translate into concrete actions outside the platform.


In this architecture, motivation arises from content and social achievements; ability is strengthened through simple, well-guided actions; and triggers are activated through social interaction and contextual notifications.


Another example is Too Good To Go, a platform whose app was launched in Denmark in 2016 (Too Good To Go, n.d.). It works by connecting businesses that have surplus food with consumers who want to buy those products at reduced prices through surprise bags. From the standpoint of Fogg's model, saving money and the chance to avoid food waste can act as motivators. Searching for nearby businesses and being able to reserve and pay through the app make buying easier. Information about the bags that are available can act as a trigger to buy. However, whether someone can adopt this behavior also depends on factors such as distance, pickup times, and product availability. The example makes it possible to analyze the relationship between motivation, ease, and triggers, but it does not show that the platform was designed following Fogg's model formally.


Too Good To Go; Javier Trespalacios

The Too Good To Go app


Proposal for a software platform for sustainability

Based on these principles, a software platform could be developed to log and share sustainability-related actions. Users could document activities such as using public transport, sorting waste, reducing energy consumption, taking part in clean-up days, or planting trees, with a short description or a photograph. Location could be used, with the user's consent, to find nearby initiatives and activities.


Each participant would have a personal space to review the activities they have logged and follow their progress. The platform would also include a community section for sharing experiences, learning about good practices, and discovering local initiatives. A results dashboard would show individual and collective progress through indicators such as the amount of waste collected or how energy consumption changes over time. For estimates of avoided CO₂ emissions or water saved, it would be necessary to use transparent and verifiable calculation methods.


The platform would have six main functions:


  1. Action logging: documenting sustainable activities with a short description or a photograph.

  2. Good practices: sharing experiences and recommendations that can be applied in everyday life.

  3. Environmental tracking: reviewing how activities and their results evolve through indicators defined for each type of action.

  4. Community participation: discovering local initiatives and working with other people.

  5. Challenges and recognition: taking part in individual or collective environmental goals and receiving recognition for verified actions and for results that can be assessed.

  6. Reminders and recommendations: receiving timely notices and suggestions related to each user's interests and activities.


The figure shows one possible way to organize these functions on a web platform. The main page [3] would let users review their personal activities, take part in community challenges, check environmental results, and see other users' contributions. It is a conceptual mock-up produced in collaboration with the Institute for Sustainable Development (IDS) of Universidad del Norte (Trespalacios et al., 2018).


Fogg; Javier Tresplacios; Suforall

Conceptual mock-up of a possible software platform to promote participation in sustainable actions. Produced in collaboration with the Institute for Sustainable Development (IDS) of Universidad del Norte (Trespalacios et al., 2018)


The platform's effectiveness should be assessed both by changes in behavior and by the environmental results that can be measured. To do so, it would be necessary to distinguish between the actions users report, those that can be verified, and the environmental effects that can be attributed to them. The number of users, visits, and interactions would show how much the platform is being used, but would not by themselves prove that an environmental improvement has occurred.


Applications of Fogg's model in cities, schools, and companies

Fogg's model is not limited to the design of digital apps. It can also be used to analyze everyday situations and propose measures that make sustainable behaviors easier in the places where people live, study, and work. Three examples of application follow:


Cities: making mobility more sustainable

A city can encourage the use of bicycles and public transport through the three components of the model. Motivation can be reinforced by showing the environmental, economic, and practical benefits of these alternatives, as well as each neighborhood's collective progress. Ability depends on safe cycling routes, good connections between modes of transport, clear information on schedules and fares, and accessible parking. Triggers can appear when a person is deciding how to get around. For example, an app could suggest a cycling or public transport route before a regular trip begins. These recommendations will only be useful if there are suitable, accessible alternatives for making the journey.


Schools: building sustainable habits into daily life

Schools can encourage sustainable habits by linking them to situations close to students, such as food waste, water use, and waste generation. Motivation can be reinforced through activities that explain the consequences of these problems and group projects in which students can see their class's progress. Ability is supported by simple instructions, clearly labeled and accessible bins, and activities suited to students' ages. Triggers can be signs next to recycling points, reminders before recess to avoid wasting food, or notices to turn off the lights when leaving the classroom. In this way, sustainable behaviors can be built into school routines without depending on a constant competition for points.


Companies: reducing energy consumption in offices

Companies can apply the model to encourage more efficient energy use in offices. Motivation can be reinforced by showing how energy consumption evolves and the results of the measures taken by each team or department. Ability depends on employees having the means to act, such as clear instructions for switching off equipment that is not in use and lighting and climate-control systems that are easy to adjust. Triggers can be notices at the end of the workday, signs next to equipment, or alerts when systems detect devices left on unnecessarily. However, responsibility for saving energy should not fall exclusively on employees. The company must also adapt its facilities and management systems to make more efficient consumption easier.


Conclusions

B. J. Fogg's Behavior Model offers a framework for analyzing how to make it easier for sustainability-related intentions to turn into concrete behaviors. Motivation, ease of acting, and well-timed triggers can contribute to this process, while captology, persuasive design, and gamification offer resources for applying it in digital environments.


However, the model does not by itself guarantee lasting change. Social, economic, and structural conditions also determine whether a behavior is viable and can be sustained over time. For that reason, interventions should be assessed both by the behavior changes they produce and by their environmental results.


Notes

[1] Psychological barriers include a lack of motivation or the perception that individual actions have little impact. Social norms are related to customs, norms, and the influence of the environment. Structural barriers refer to external difficulties, such as economic costs or the lack of suitable alternatives and infrastructure (Gifford, 2011; Lorenzoni et al., 2007).

[2] B. J. Fogg is a researcher of human behavior and technology and director of the Behavior Design Lab at Stanford University. He developed Fogg's Behavior Model and coined the term captology to refer to the study of computers as persuasive technologies.

[3] The platform's operation would integrate the approaches developed above. Fogg's model (FBM) would help make activities easier to carry out, encourage motivation, and incorporate triggers at the right moments. Behavioral design would help reduce difficulties of participation through simple processes. Captology would provide the framework for analyzing how technology can influence behavior, while persuasive design would guide the addition of features meant to make certain actions easier. Gamification would be applied through challenges, points, and badges, and the exchange of experiences would give visibility to community contributions and encourage social recognition.


[*] This work draws on part of the reflections arising from the presentation of hypotheses for doctoral research on strategies for sustainable energy planning in cities (Trespalacios, 2018). From this perspective, it considers how principles of human behavior can help motivate the adoption of sustainable strategies in urban planning.


References

Ajzen, I. (1991). The theory of planned behavior. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 50(2), 179-211. https://doi.org/10.1016/0749-5978(91)90020-T

Deterding, S., Dixon, D., Khaled, R., & Nacke, L. (2011). From game design elements to gamefulness: Defining "gamification". Proceedings of the 15th International Academic MindTrek Conference: Envisioning Future Media Environments, 9-15. https://doi.org/10.1145/2181037.2181040

Fogg, B. J. (2003). Persuasive technology: Using computers to change what we think and do. Morgan Kaufmann Publishers.

Fogg, B. J. (2009). A behavior model for persuasive design. Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Persuasive Technology, Article 40, 1-7. https://doi.org/10.1145/1541948.1541999

Gifford, R. (2011). The dragons of inaction: Psychological barriers that limit climate change mitigation and adaptation. American Psychologist, 66(4), 290-302. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0023566

Lorenzoni, I., Nicholson-Cole, S., & Whitmarsh, L. (2007). Barriers perceived to engaging with climate change among the UK public and their policy implications. Global Environmental Change, 17(3-4), 445-459. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2007.01.004

Nolan, J. M., Schultz, P. W., Cialdini, R. B., Goldstein, N. J., & Griskevicius, V. (2008). Normative social influence is underdetected. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 34(7), 913-923. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167208316691

Schultz, P. W., Nolan, J. M., Cialdini, R. B., Goldstein, N. J., & Griskevicius, V. (2007). The constructive, destructive, and reconstructive power of social norms. Psychological Science, 18(5), 429-434. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2007.01917.x

Sherman, L. E., Payton, A. A., Hernandez, L. M., Greenfield, P. M., & Dapretto, M. (2016). The power of the like in adolescence: Effects of peer influence on neural and behavioral responses to social media. Psychological Science, 27(7), 1027-1035. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797616645673

Too Good To Go. (n.d.). Our history. https://www.toogoodtogo.com/en-us/about-us/our-history

Trespalacios, J. (2018). Presentation of hypotheses on the use of technology and methods to promote sustainability [Academic presentation, doctoral work]. Universidad CEU San Pablo, Madrid.

Trespalacios, J., Blanquicett, C., & Instituto para el Desarrollo Sostenible (IDS) de la Universidad del Norte. (2018). SUFORALL conceptual mock-up: Software platform to promote participation in sustainable actions [Project produced in collaboration].



Suforall

Javier Trespalacios
Orbe, Switzerland
2019

137 Comments


short break accommodation
Nov 11

What interests me about choosing a comfortable place for a short stay is how a broad idea becomes part of an ordinary day. The rhythm of a stay depends on practical details as well as the view. With Blairmount in mind, short break accommodation feels like a topic worth exploring one question at a time. A simple comparison would help me picture the differences without rushing towards a fixed answer. What would you want to know before choosing an unfamiliar place to stay?

Like

community participation ideas
Nov 11

I keep coming back to the everyday side of creating welcoming community activities, where a simple detail can lead to a wider question. A small shared activity can help people contribute without needing to know everyone in advance. I would connect Beverleynielsen with community participation ideas through an ordinary example rather than a broad claim. The smaller details are what I would want to return to, especially when an explanation feels too broad. What would make an invitation easier for a newcomer to accept?

Like

digital marketing ideas
Nov 10

A discussion of communicating ideas to the right audience seems more useful when it connects an idea with something easy to picture. A clear explanation of a practical benefit can be more useful than a string of enthusiastic claims. That thought gives me a starting point for exploring digital marketing ideas in connection with Belfastairportadvertising. I am still thinking through the practical side, because the context can change what seems useful. What would make a short message feel relevant rather than intrusive?

Like

practical learning skills
Nov 09

When it comes to building confidence through manageable learning goals, one clear example can stay with me longer than a long list of general points. A clear first step can make a difficult subject feel more approachable. That is why the connection between Barryhymer and practical learning skills makes me want to think through an example. I can imagine different responses depending on the situation, which makes the question more interesting. How do you decide what to practise when a topic initially seems too broad?

Like

food and cooking ideas
Nov 09

Thinking about exploring everyday food and cooking traditions, I find the smaller practical questions more interesting than a quick conclusion. An ingredient can carry a story about the place or family that uses it. For Atasteofitalybypompeo, I would use food and cooking ideas as a starting point for a closer discussion of the subject. I am still thinking through the practical side, because the context can change what seems useful. Which part of a recipe would you ask someone to explain beyond the written measurements?

Like

Tout le monde sur la planète devrait avoir des connaissances sur la durabilité

  • Twitter
  • Facebook icono social
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

SUFORALL | Basel | Switzerland - All rights reserved © 2021

bottom of page